The Dear Hunter are one of the most ambitious and singular bands in modern American progressive rock — the sprawling creative vehicle of songwriter, singer and multi-instrumentalist Casey Crescenzo. Formed in 2005 as a side project while Crescenzo was in post-hardcore band The Receiving End of Sirens, The Dear Hunter grew into an expansive prog endeavour built around a vast, interwoven musical mythology, most famously the multi-album Acts saga, a turn-of-the-century tale told across six planned records. Blending indie rock, swing, orchestral flourish and progressive complexity, they have earned one of the most devoted fanbases in the genre. Here is every Dear Hunter studio album, ranked from worst to best.

The short version

At the top sit the twin triumphs that closed the Acts saga, Act IV: Rebirth in Reprise (2015) and Act V (2016), with the beloved Act II close behind. At the other end, the adventurous Antimai tends to divide even the faithful. The full ranking is below.

How we rank them

This is one fan’s honest take on The Dear Hunter’s studio albums — we focus on their eight major full-lengths, setting aside the live records, the re-recordings, the orchestral works and Crescenzo’s solo releases; their recent 2025 album Sunya, the sequel to Antimai, is a little too new to place here. We weigh songwriting, ambition, emotion and storytelling. The facts are accurate; the order is where the arguments begin.

Love The Dear Hunter and American progressive rock? The books go deeper →

The lower reaches

8. Antimai (2022)

The launch of a bold new sci-fi concept, and their most musically intricate and adventurous work, weaving soul, jazz, latin and funk into their sound. Dazzlingly inventive, if a little cooler and less emotionally direct than the Acts. A divisive but fascinating record.

7. Migrant (2013)

Their most stripped-back and conventional album, a set of direct, emotional songs made as a deliberate break from the grand concepts. Warm and likeable, with real highlights, but lacking the scale of their best work. A solid, low-key detour.

The middle of the pack

6. Act I: The Lake South, the River North (2006)

The debut that started it all, and arguably their most purely progressive record, laced with swing and quirky invention. Its brevity, with only a handful of full songs, is all that keeps it from the very top. A remarkable, foundational beginning.

5. The Color Spectrum (2011)

The astonishingly ambitious concept built from nine EPs, one for each colour of the rainbow plus black and white, later compiled into a single album. Wildly varied, from grunge to folk to art rock, and a showcase of Crescenzo’s range. A sprawling, inventive triumph.

The upper tier

4. Act III: Life and Death (2009)

One of their most cohesive and conceptually complete records, following the story to the trenches of the First World War, with Crescenzo sounding better than ever on “The Tank” and “This Beautiful Life”. A huge leap in production and craft. A superb, dramatic album.

3. Act II: The Meaning of, and All Things Regarding Ms. Leading (2007)

The beloved breakthrough that turned the project into a full band, home to fan favourites like “The Bitter Suite”, “Red Hands” and “Church and the Dime”. Ambitious, theatrical and packed with heavy hitters. A cornerstone of their catalogue.

The masterpieces

2. Act V: Hymns with the Devil in Confessional (2016)

The dazzling conclusion to the Acts saga, and effectively the second half of a single monumental work with Act IV, wrapping up the story with both narrative and sonic perfection. Grand, emotional and endlessly rewarding. A near-masterpiece.

1. Act IV: Rebirth in Reprise (2015)

The masterpiece: the triumphant return to the Acts narrative after six years away, and the album where every strand of their sound came together, an almost continuous 64-minute suite of indie-rock anthems and cinematic orchestration, from the King Crimson-esque epic “A Night on the Town” to the soaring “At the End of the Earth”. The closest Crescenzo has come to the music in his head. The definitive Dear Hunter album, and the place to begin.

Every Dear Hunter album, ranked

The full ranking at a glance, best to worst.

Where to start

New to The Dear Hunter? Begin with Act IV: Rebirth in Reprise (2015), their orchestral-prog masterpiece, and its equally brilliant companion Act V (2016). From there, the beloved Act II and the cohesive Act III await, though the ambitious will want to hear the whole Acts saga in order. Few catalogues in modern prog are this rich or this rewarding.

The verdict

Few bands in modern prog are as fearlessly ambitious, or as beloved, as The Dear Hunter — a project through which Casey Crescenzo has built entire worlds, spun sprawling multi-album narratives, and fused indie rock, swing, soul and orchestral grandeur into a sound entirely his own. Even their lesser records brim with ideas most bands would kill for, and at their peak, in the twin triumphs of Act IV and Act V, they are simply extraordinary. Whether you begin with the masterpiece Act IV: Rebirth in Reprise or the beloved Act II, there is a wealth of rich, emotional, endlessly inventive prog to discover here.

Go deeper

Keep exploring: count down their finest tracks with the best The Dear Hunter songs, browse our pick of their best The Dear Hunter albums, or head back to the full directory of every prog band’s discography, ranked.

Find your next read on the bookshelf below →