What a Supertramp listener is loyal to is a finish rather than a genre: a song shaped like a pop song, a keyboard carrying the tune, a reed instrument answering it, and a studio used as an instrument rather than a room to hurry through. That combination is scarcer than it sounds. This guide to the best prog rock albums for Supertramp fans names six records, none of them by Supertramp, which already has pages here. Every choice is attached to the band by something documented: the same label in the same years, the same studio a year apart, a founding member who wrote words elsewhere, a player who is on the record itself.

Steely Dan — Aja (1977)

The bridge is a room. Aja was cut in part at the Village Recorder in west Los Angeles, and Supertramp took the same building from May to December 1978 to make Breakfast in America: the same rooms, about a year apart. It is songcraft assembled from session players rather than a fixed line-up, with no seam left showing. Issued on ABC, it reached number 5 on the Official Albums Chart and number 3 on the Billboard 200, and Pitchfork later called it “as much a jazz record as a pop one”.

Styx — The Grand Illusion (1977)

A label bridge, and a long one. A&M signed Styx in 1975 and kept them for the next nine years, so the Chicago band and the London one sat in the same company’s hands across the run that produced Even in the Quietest Moments... and Breakfast in America; Supertramp had been an A&M act since their 1970 debut. The music rhymes with that: keyboards and guitars sharing the lead, prog structure aimed squarely at the singles chart. Recorded at Paragon Recording Studios in Chicago and released in July 1977, it sold three million copies in the United States, and Classic Rock has ranked its title track the band’s greatest song.

Strawbs — Hero and Heroine (1974)

The same roster, earlier and much more English. Strawbs were the first British group A&M signed, in June 1968, and were still delivering albums to the label in 1975, which places this record inside the years Supertramp spent on the same books. Rebuilt around its two singer-guitarists after the previous line-up came apart, the band sets organ, piano and mellotron alongside the guitars, and Rolling Stone has described its move from folk towards a lush, mellotron-led sound. Recorded at Rosenberg Studios in Copenhagen, it reached number 35 on the Official Albums Chart, and the same magazine later placed it 44th in its ranking of the 50 greatest progressive rock albums.

Rick Wakeman — Journey to the Centre of the Earth (1974)

A&M once more, and here the label is the story: its British division resisted the record, and the co-founder of the company ordered a worldwide release over their objection, in the same year the firm put out Crime of the Century. Taped in concert at the Royal Festival Hall in January 1974 with the London Symphony Orchestra and a chamber choir, an actor narrating between the orchestral sections, it went to number 1 on the Official Albums Chart and spent thirty weeks on that chart in all, and Melody Maker called it “entertaining, fresh and disarmingly unpretentious”.

King Crimson — Larks’ Tongues in Aspic (1973)

The strongest link on the page belongs to the least obvious record. The guitarist who co-founded Supertramp and wrote the words on its 1970 debut supplied the lyrics for this album, and for the two King Crimson albums that followed in 1974, without playing a note on any of them. He was writing for a line-up that had just added violin and a percussion table to the guitar, bass and drums. Issued on Island in Britain and Atlantic in America, it reached number 20 on the Official Albums Chart, and the Billboard review of the day called it “without doubt the finest set yet”.

The Pineapple Thief — Your Wilderness (2016)

The modern entry, with the bridge printed in the credits: the clarinet is played by the saxophonist and clarinettist who joined Supertramp in 1973, the string arrangements come from a viola player out of Caravan, and the drums from a player better known for Porcupine Tree and King Crimson. That is a Supertramp voice inside a current prog record. Released in August 2016 on Kscope, the label the band has been on since 2008, it runs on short pieces with one long track near the end. Prog praised the way its unhurried arrangements leave room for mellotron, piano and synthesisers.

Where to start

Aja is the easy door: familiar, warm, closer to the craft of Breakfast in America than to anything difficult. The Grand Illusion next, which asks only a tolerance for big American choruses, then Hero and Heroine, the most English record here. Your Wilderness is the low-effort modern option. Journey to the Centre of the Earth wants patience, since an orchestra and a narrator carry the story rather than a band carrying a song. Leave Larks’ Tongues in Aspic until last: the hardest listen here, and the one tied most tightly to the band you came in for.

Go deeper

Two threads run on from here. The last record above carries string arrangements by a Caravan man, which makes the Caravan recommendations page the natural next stop, with a beginner’s guide to their albums beside it. The studio-built side has its own route: the Steely Dan guide works the same method from the other direction, and the Alan Parsons Project page covers the British project that pushed studio building furthest. The map for the series is Prog Rock Recommendations: What to Listen to Next.

Back towards the band that sent you here, the beginner’s guide to the essential Supertramp records sorts the catalogue album by album and the band page gathers the rest. Neighbouring guides start elsewhere: Electric Light Orchestra, which also has a beginner’s guide, plus Kansas and Mike Oldfield. The wider canon is at The Best Progressive Rock Albums of All Time. A book-length account of the British scene, Beyond the Thames, in the Beyond the Sound series, covers the same ground at greater length.

Enjoyed the read? Find your next one on the bookshelf below →