Octopus is Gentle Giant’s masterpiece — eight perfectly formed pieces, thirty-four minutes long, in which medieval counterpoint, hard rock, jazz and pure invention collide without a single wasted bar. Released in 1972 in a famous Roger Dean sleeve, it is the album that made converts, and the one most often handed to newcomers.

The short version

Octopus (1972) is the fourth studio album by Gentle Giant, self-produced at Advision Studios. Its title, reportedly coined by Phil Shulman’s wife, is a pun on ‘octo opus’ — eight musical works. It is a pivotal record: the last with eldest brother Phil, and the first with drummer John Weathers, who would stay to the end. Home to the astonishing a cappella ‘Knots’ and the thundering ‘The Advent of Panurge,’ it is widely considered their finest hour.

A hinge in the story

Gentle Giant arrived at Octopus having already made three remarkable albums, but two things changed here. John Weathers came in on drums, replacing Malcolm Mortimore, and immediately gave the band a harder, more physical foundation — the music rocks in a way it never quite had before. And Phil Shulman, the eldest of the three brothers, played his last: the relentless touring schedule, at the end of the Octopus tour, took him back to his family. His warm voice and horns would be missed, and the band would carry on as a quintet. Behind the desk was Martin Rushent, who a few years later would help define the sound of British new wave.

The sound

Everything Gentle Giant can do, they do here, and they do it in miniature. Songs of three and four minutes contain more ideas than most bands manage in twenty. Kerry Minnear ranges across organ, Minimoog, harpsichord, vibraphone and cello; Ray Shulman plays bass and violin with equal fluency; Gary Green’s guitar is sharp and bluesy; the three lead voices — Derek’s hoarse power, Phil’s warmth, Minnear’s high tenor — interlock like clockwork. Medieval melody sits beside wordless jazz-rock pieces, chamber strings beside distortion. And the vocal counterpoint reaches a peak that rock has seldom approached before or since.

The songs

‘The Advent of Panurge’ opens on a swaggering bass-and-organ riff and tells, from Rabelais, of the giant Pantagruel meeting Panurge on a bridge. ‘Raconteur Troubadour’ hides a lovely trick: beneath the chorus, the violin quietly plays the melody of the verse. ‘A Cry for Everyone’ is the heaviest thing on the record, and ‘Knots’ — a partly unaccompanied vocal fugue, its words taken from a book of poems by R. D. Laing, with a xylophone solo from John Weathers — is their signature feat. ‘The Boys in the Band’ is a wordless jazz-rock piece, and Kerry Minnear’s tender ‘Think of Me with Kindness’ is a perfect farewell.

Reception and legacy

Octopus did not turn around the band’s commercial fortunes: they remained, as Derek Shulman wryly put it, a group with no profile at home. Time has settled the argument. It is now routinely named their greatest album and one of the essential progressive records of the 1970s, admired by musicians far beyond the genre, and remixed decades later by Steven Wilson as a mark of its standing. Roger Dean’s gatefold became iconic in its own right. Above all, Octopus is the album where Gentle Giant’s staggering ambition finally fits into perfect, compact shape.

The verdict

Octopus is essential Gentle Giant and, along with Free Hand, the ideal place to begin. Nothing here outstays its welcome, nothing repeats, and every listen uncovers a countermelody you had not noticed before. It is complex without being cold, virtuosic without being smug, and often, unexpectedly, very beautiful. Come for the muscle of ‘The Advent of Panurge,’ marvel at ‘Knots,’ and stay for ‘Think of Me with Kindness’ — thirty-four minutes that justify an entire career.

Browse the bookshelf in the footer →