Emerson, Lake & Palmer were one of the defining supergroups of progressive rock — three virtuosos who fused rock with classical grandeur on a colossal scale. Keith Emerson’s keyboard pyrotechnics, Greg Lake’s warm voice and melodies and Carl Palmer’s thunderous drumming made them among the biggest, and most divisive, bands of the 1970s. Across nine studio albums they reached for the stars. Here is our fellow fan’s ranking of every one.

The short version

For the heart of ELP, start with Brain Salad Surgery, Tarkus, Trilogy, the self-titled debut Emerson, Lake & Palmer and Works Volume 1. Between them they hold the band’s landmark suites and best-loved songs. The full ranking is below.

Three virtuosos, classical ambition

ELP brought together three already-famous players: keyboardist Keith Emerson of The Nice, singer-bassist Greg Lake of King Crimson, and drummer Carl Palmer. Together they fused rock with classical grandeur — adapting Mussorgsky and Copland, writing sprawling suites and staging some of the most spectacular shows of the era. They were also among the most divisive bands of their day: critics often mocked their bombast even as audiences thrilled to their ambition and skill. Time has been kinder, recognising them as pioneers of what the genre could attempt.

How we ranked them

This is one fan’s order, weighing composition, performance and ambition across a career of soaring highs and a few notorious lows. The facts are accurate; the order is a starting point for the debate — though on the classic run, there is little dispute.

The essential five

At the top sits Brain Salad Surgery (1973), for many their masterpiece, crowned by the colossal three-part “Karn Evil 9”. Its great rival is Tarkus (1971), built around a ferocious side-long suite that remains a landmark of the genre. Trilogy (1972) is a polished, melodic high point, and the self-titled debut Emerson, Lake & Palmer (1970) announced the band fully formed, home to the enduring “Lucky Man”. Works Volume 1 (1977) is the ambitious orchestral double — uneven but containing some of their grandest music, including “Pirates”.

Thrilled by the spectacle? The books go deeper →

Reliably great

The next tier is more of a mixed bag, but worthwhile. Black Moon (1992) is the respectable reunion album, a genuine return to their keyboard-driven prog after years apart; Works Volume 2 (1977) gathers shorter pieces and odds and ends, varied in quality but with its share of gems.

For completists

Two albums sit at the foot of the list. In the Hot Seat (1994), the final reunion record, is widely seen as a weak farewell, and Love Beach (1978) is famously their low point — a contractual-obligation album that even the band disowned. Both are strictly for the dedicated.

Every studio album, in order

Every studio album, 1970–1994, in chronological order; their famous live adaptation of Mussorgsky’s “Pictures at an Exhibition” sits outside this selection. Click through to the full write-up on any record.

Where to start

Begin with Brain Salad Surgery — the fullest expression of everything ELP did, from epic suite to delicate ballad. From there, Tarkus is the essential early statement, and the self-titled debut offers “Lucky Man” and their first burst of brilliance.

The players

ELP were three masters of their instruments. Keith Emerson, of The Nice, was among rock’s greatest and most flamboyant keyboardists, a pioneer of the Moog synthesizer; Greg Lake, of King Crimson, brought the warm voice and melodic songcraft behind their ballads; and Carl Palmer, later of Asia, was a drummer of dazzling power and precision. Both Keith Emerson and Greg Lake sadly passed away in 2016, leaving Palmer as the sole surviving member — and a tireless keeper of their legacy.

Why they still matter

For all the arguments about excess, ELP expanded the ambition of progressive rock like few others — proving rock could meet classical music head-on and play to stadiums while doing it. Alongside symphonic peers like Yes, they defined the grand, virtuosic side of the genre — and their best suites still astonish with their scale and daring.

Go deeper

Keep exploring: read about the best Emerson, Lake & Palmer songs, see every ELP album in order, find your way in with our where-to-start-with-ELP guide, or dig up the most underrated ELP albums. You can also place them in the bigger picture with our list of the best progressive rock albums of all time.

Find your next read on the bookshelf below →