The story begins. Act I: The Lake South, the River North is The Dear Hunter’s 2006 debut: the opening chapter of one of modern prog’s most ambitious storytelling sagas.

The short version

The 2006 debut album by American progressive rock band The Dear Hunter — and the first chapter of an ambitious, multi-album concept saga. The creation of mastermind Casey Crescenzo, it introduces the story of a boy known only as ‘The Dear Hunter,’ set at the dawn of the twentieth century, through a lush blend of progressive rock, chamber pop and indie rock. A promising, atmospheric start to a beloved series.

Where the saga begins

The Dear Hunter began as a side project for Casey Crescenzo, a way to explore music that didn’t fit his previous band. After stepping away to focus on it full-time, he wrote and recorded Act I: The Lake South, the River North largely on his own, with his brother Nick on drums and family and friends lending a hand. The album is the opening act of a planned six-part story following the life of a boy at the turn of the twentieth century, and his relationship with his mother. Rough around the edges compared to what came later, it nonetheless lays the groundwork — musically and narratively — for one of prog’s most beloved sagas.

The sound

Lush, theatrical and genre-blending, Act I fuses progressive rock with chamber pop, indie rock, jazz and orchestral flourish. Casey Crescenzo — who plays most of the instruments himself — builds rich, cinematic arrangements around his expressive vocals, layering horns, piano, organ and guitar into an atmospheric, story-driven whole. The production is modest compared to the band’s later work, but the ambition is already clear: this is music built to tell a story, full of recurring themes and motifs that would pay off across the saga to come.

Reading up on American prog? The books go deeper →

The songs

The album opens with the brief instrumental Battesimo del Fuoco before easing into its narrative. City Escape is an early highlight, all drama and momentum, while the seven-minute 1878 is the album’s most expansive and ambitious piece. The closing The River North brings the first chapter to an atmospheric, unresolved end — a cliffhanger that sets the stage for everything to follow. Throughout, Crescenzo’s knack for melody and mood shines through.

Reception and legacy

Act I: The Lake South, the River North was a promising debut that introduced Casey Crescenzo’s remarkable storytelling ambition. Often considered the roughest of the Acts — being the first, and largely a solo effort — it has nonetheless grown in stature as the saga has unfolded, its quiet details and motifs paying off in the acclaimed later chapters. For fans of the series, it is where a rich, sprawling musical world begins.

The verdict

A promising, atmospheric and ambitious debut, and the essential first chapter of The Dear Hunter’s celebrated concept saga: lush, theatrical progressive rock built around Casey Crescenzo’s storytelling and multi-instrumental craft. Come for the dramatic City Escape and the expansive 1878 — and stay for the story that unfolds across the later Acts. Rougher than what followed, but rich with promise, it is the perfect place to begin one of modern prog’s most rewarding journeys.

Browse the bookshelf in the footer →