Five years on from ‘The Masquerade Overture’, Pendragon returned with a warmer, more expansive set of long multi-part suites carried by Nick Barrett’s lead vocals — among the band’s most-loved records for neo-prog listeners.

The short version

‘Not of This World’ arrived in June 2001 and kept Pendragon’s classic quartet intact: Nick Barrett on guitars and lead vocals, Clive Nolan on keyboards, Peter Gee on bass, and Fudge Smith on drums. Where earlier albums leaned symphonic, this one spreads out into big, multi-section pieces while keeping Barrett’s melody and voice front and centre. Wikipedia groups it with ‘The Window of Life’ and ‘The Masquerade Overture’ as the run in which the band settled into its mature style, and many neo-prog listeners hold it up as a fan favourite. It is accessible without being slight: the songs are long, but they move on melody and mood rather than technical density, which makes it another common entry point for the newcomer.

Pendragon’s early-2000s fan favourite

By 2001 Pendragon were among the most established names in British neo-prog, and ‘Not of This World’ found them working with a settled line-up and a clear identity. Nick Barrett wrote and sang the material, played guitars, and shaped the direction; Clive Nolan supplied the keyboard textures, Peter Gee the bass, and Fudge Smith the drums — the same four who had carried the band through the previous decade. The album is organised around long-form songs, several split into named parts, so it plays almost as a suite of linked pieces rather than a set of singles. It opens with ‘If I Were the Wind (and You Were the Rain)’ and closes with the two-part ‘World’s End’, with the three-part title track at its heart.

The sound

This is expansive, melodic neo-prog: the songs run long and unfold in stages, but they are anchored by clear tunes rather than by technical fireworks. Nolan’s keyboards provide the backdrop and the swells, while Barrett’s guitar carries most of the melodic weight, stepping out for the extended solos the style favours. Critics generally describe the album as warm and direct, more interested in feel and momentum than in sudden metrical twists, and they note how the multi-part structures let a single idea grow across many minutes. Because the pieces are built from linked sections, the record rewards listening in long stretches rather than by single track. Reviewers place it on the accessible, song-led side of progressive rock.

Reading up on neo-prog? The books go deeper →

The songs

‘If I Were the Wind (and You Were the Rain)’ opens the album, easing in on melody before the band widens the frame. ‘Not of This World’ is the three-part title suite at the centre of the album, moving through distinct sections while keeping Barrett’s vocal line as its thread. ‘World’s End’ closes the set as a two-part finale, the kind of long, building piece Pendragon use to draw an album to a close. Taken together, the opener, the title suite, and the closer show how the album is built from linked, extended songs rather than short, self-contained tracks.

Reception and legacy

Among neo-prog listeners ‘Not of This World’ is frequently named a fan favourite, and it is often grouped with the band’s 1990s work as part of their strongest run — a framing Wikipedia echoes when it lists the album alongside ‘The Window of Life’ and ‘The Masquerade Overture’. Reviewers tend to praise its melodic reach and the scale of its long-form writing, while noting that its unhurried pace asks for patient listening.

The verdict

‘Not of This World’ is for the listener who likes progressive rock that takes its time — long songs that grow by melody and mood rather than by constant change. It is one of the friendlier ways into Pendragon and into melodic neo-prog as a whole, and it holds up as a favourite for people who already know the band. Anyone who prefers short, sharp, angular prog may find it too even-tempered, and that is worth saying plainly.

Browse the bookshelf in the footer →